An American Writer's Thoughts on Japanese Animation

How Much Lore Does It Take to Justify Cute Ship Girls? A Prelude to Azur Lane

The upcoming Azur Lane anime is… something that is weirdly in my interest. I was never really a gacha game or phone game sort of person, but I’ve been playing around on Azur Lane for most of a year now; it has some decent character writing and is overall very friendly to casual players. When I heard they were going to make an anime based on the game, though, I was… less than thrilled. It would be cool to see some of my favorite characters moving around and doing things in a more fully realized world, but adapting video games, at least ones that aren’t visual novels, into other media has historically been very thorny. True, anime does this a little better than Western media; Granblue Fantasy the Animation was… not exactly what I’d call good, but it does look a little like Citizen Kane when you put it next to the filmography of Uwe Boll (probably the West’s most famous or perhaps infamous adapter of video games). But in any case there would have to be care taken and effort output in order to make an Azur Lane anime good.

Read More…Read More…

Surveying the Damage One Character can do to a Show – Kaze no Stigma Spoiler Review

Kaze no Stigma is a show that started out with a lot of potential, but squandered it by making some very basic mistakes. The setup involves a society of magic users that exist secretly in what is essentially our regular mundane world – the backbone of at least a sizeable subset of the broad genre of “Urban Fantasy” that combines magic and monsters with the trappings of the mundane world. Good so far. Our main character is Kazuma, the scion of a house of fire magic wielders who was kicked out of his family because he was, himself, incapable… and who returns with a new mastery of a different element, Air. That’s a pretty good setup for a character. The show puts him in a position to help his former family in their time of need, but of course he should have some conflicted opinions about that, considering that he was bitterly mistreated. A good treatment would let us learn more about the character through his struggles, understanding what happened to him in the interval to lead him to this new power and how his trials shaped him and will continue to shape him going forward.

Kaze no Stigma… does not deliver a good treatment of this material. There’s more to worry about outside of Kazuma, but I’m going start with him because his problems are the most numerous and varied and his waste of potential the most striking.

Read More…Read More…

The Many-Worlds Interpretation Makes for Surprising Drama – Noein Spoiler Review

Quantum physics comes up surprisingly often in media. Perhaps it’s because it’s on the arcane end of current science, and thus it’s fairly easy to use it as a line of plausible BS to cover for whatever the writer wants to happen. It wouldn’t be the first discipline to get that treatment: just about any science fiction technology becomes instantly more plausible if you put “nano” in front of it, while there was infamously a period of writing where atomic or radioactive anything could accomplish just about any goal. And there’s probably a wealth of forgotten stories from the infancy of electric power that similarly treated it as applied sorcery.

Noein may have its fair share of ‘might as well be magic’, but I felt like it took it a more serious look at what its ‘quantum’ arcana would actually imply, and ran with the storytelling possibilities of applying quantum realities on the scale of human events.

Read More…Read More…

You Got Your Exploration of AI and Humanity in My Shipgirl Action Show! Arpeggio of Blue Steel Spoiler Review

A lot of shows try to be more than one thing. It makes sense, letting them find appeal on some tracks even if others fall through. And all too often, reaching for more than was necessary causes the work to fail on all marks. Similarly, you sometimes get shows that aren’t smart, but want you to think they are, resulting in a pretentious mess that didn’t need to be one and could have worked if it embraced a simple core. These are pretty common results.

Arpeggio of Blue Steel is exactly the opposite of that. It’s a show that reaches for a couple of things, but achieves them all as well as it was going to. And it’s a show that has a very intelligent core, but while not exactly being ashamed of its intelligence largely doesn’t draw attention to it, being humble rather than pretentious. It’s not a masterpiece by any means, but it’s worth some deeper investigation.

Read More…Read More…