Shigofumi follows one of those supernatural concepts that would be completely warping to the reality we know if it existed, but that for the purpose of telling a connectable story is largely written off as being true but not widely believed. That is that, per the subtitle, letters from the departed: a dead person can send a letter to be delivered to the living, containing their true final feelings.
Sure, let’s go with that.
This show loosely follows Fumika, a mail carrier for the Shigofumi, and her talking staff Kanaka, who together have the job of ensuring that the words of the dead reach their intended recipients. However, this show wears a bit of Boogiepop on its sleeve. Not only does the mail carrier outfit have some lines and colors in common with that other spook, but Fumika is actually fairly underplayed most of the time. The Shigofumi delivery is always an important part of the episode, even its inciting action, but the scenes around Fumika don’t need to be terribly numerous or terribly long compared to those for the recipients.
The first arc covers two episodes. It begins with a boy and a girl who seem to be pretty close (with the boy even wanting to confess) when the girl receives news that her father has been found dead. Soon enough, Fumika arives with a Shigofumi, from the girl’s father addressed to her lover. Feeling uncomfortable leaving the dad’s last words on the table, the boy offers that while he and the girl may not be an item yet, he’ll nail the confession so he can receive the letter. Since his desire to home-build a rocket brought them together, he hopes to get the rocket to fly and use that to confess.
However, after a good deal of buildup, it seems the upper brass of this system, the Gospel Department, decided to hand it over a bit prematurely, as the staff leaves the letter behind where the boy can read it. The contents are something he finds disturbing, that the father claims that the girl murdered him, and that her lover should turn her in. The boy believes intensely in his crush and has some pretty harsh recriminations for Fumika (who claims that Shigofumi can’t contain lies), but when this argument happens in front of the girl she panics and stabs him dead.
The second episode largely concerns the girl’s circumstances, and her attempts to live after committing multiple homicides. Particularly, we learn that her father was abusive and prostituted her out, and that she killed him when he revealed that he was going to start doing the same to her innocent little sister. She makes a good effort to change her style and go on the run, but Fumika now has a delivery for her, which is a bit difficult to force her to accept.

After finally taking the letter (at supernatural gunpoint. I guess Shigofumi carriers have to have some protection) and reading it, she finds the boy really did care for her, and even used his last message not to recriminate her but to apologize for not understanding her situation. This causes her to ditch her flight plan, go back to their hangout, and try to launch the rocket for him. The cops catch up with her there, and there’s a bit of a misunderstanding: a gust of wind causes a tarp to stick to the rocket, and when she runs up with a box cutter to cut it free, the rookie cop takes it as her rushing the older cop with the blade and shoots her dead. She manages the cut and gets to see the rocket fly before lamenting that she probably won’t see the boy on the other side, given that he was a good person while she sees herself as bound for hell.
As the stinger, her own letter is delivered to the little sister by Fumika. We don’t hear its contents, but we can presume it was more of the heartfelt, positive sort of thing.
From there we move on, and I will glaze over the letters of the week to address the meta-plot. It seems Fumika is not a normal member of the Shigofumi delivery force, given that she grows like a human rather than being in fixed form like a spirit should be. Also, a boy who witnesses one of her deliveries recognizes her as his former crush, and starts to do sleuthing. He discovers (with the help of a girl with a crush on him) that the “real” Fumika has been in a coma for the last three years, so you can kind of guess that she’s astral projecting or such.
We catch up when she has a delivery to make to her father, a famous writer who she also supposedly shot in the past, before falling into that coma. He may have deserved it, though, as he’s a beauty-obsessed narcissist with negative empathy towards other people.
His response to someone being ugly.
Fumika tries to get him to remember what reality is in addition to delivering the posthumous fan letter (which he wants to burn because the handwriting is bad but fire is pretty), but a few misunderstandings get a gun into dad’s hand, which he uses on her. Oops.
Fumika proves moderately impervious to bullets, while her dad is rather vulnerable to a punch in the face, so this ends with him locked in a back room for a bit while Fumika gets out her backstoy, how she was abused as a child thanks to dad’s extreme mood swings, and developed a case of multiple personalities. The innocent good-girl personality, Fumi, is in the coma in the hospital, broken from the guilt of thinking she shot her dad while the coping mechanism personality, Mika, is the Fumika who acts as a Shigofumi Postal Worker, evidently both real enough and dead enough to count for the Powers That Be. The boy who once had a crush on her and the girl (who was also friends with Fumika) agree to help her try to bring her living self around by visiting the hospital and talking to her while the girl’s elder sister, as dad’s manager, is set to force his comeuppance.
After a little hang time with a couple of cases of the week (one involving another postal worker, who ends up being the recipient of a very special shigofumi), Fumi.
This becomes the backbone of the final real arc. Mika wants to have her existence ended to atone for what she did to Fumi. Fumi wants to reclaim her life, whatever the cost. And the friends kind of want both Fumikas to be okay.
At first, it looks like Mika gets her wish and is shot by Fumi. Fumi manages to press charges against her father, ultimately seeing him arrested but causing her to become the center of attention, which between gossipy classmates and paparazzi starts to gnaw at her sanity. The friends enter maybe-ever-after land, and provide assists here and there. Eventually, when Fumi has a mental break, it turns out that Mika was not gone, and the two of them kind of have a brawl regarding their differences

The end result is that all involved know both Fumikas are going to move forward, despite the relationship between Fumi and Mika being very much “it’s complicated”.
There is a thirteenth episode occasionally cordoned off into OVA territory, but honestly it’s a pretty decent capstone. In some ways, it’s a sequel to a running trend of deaths-by-bullying at a particular school, where a victim’s sister uses her knowledge of Shigofumi to fake them and make the bullies think they’re subject to some horrible curse. Fumi, now attending the school, knows better. Fumi is also being bullied, but the culprit looks out for her in a small way that means that Fumi doesn’t want to see the culprit suffer horrible karma from actually doing anything to the bullies. In the end, Fumi tries to scare her kinda-friend straight, only for Mika to show up and sort them both out. To an extent, status quo is restored, but we can now believe Fumi is properly on the mend.
The actual end.
So, Shigofumi is not a show to watch if you’re in a volatile mental state. There’s a lot of misery, despair, and suicide. On the surface it doesn’t look all that much worse than any other show with an afterlife theme, but I promise you, this one hits pretty hard. There’s a certain hopelessness and futility in Shigofumi where, despite this mystical gift (or because of this mystical curse), life and society are going to drag people down anyway. Naturally, every letter of the week has to involve a dead person, and many of them don’t provide a lot of light no matter where in the episode the letter is delivered. The core story of Fumika helps a little, because people really do grow through it, but even then we’re still dealing with themes that are heavy as lead, watching a father carve his writing into his daughter’s skin while entering a psychotic, violent state over her deadbeat mom.
I’m not the kind of person to plaster “Content Warning!” on everything, but in its down-to-earth portrayal, I feel like Shigofumi is particularly traumatizing and thus particularly deserving of at least a note that it’s potentially hazardous to mental health.
Now, granted, said note does not say an awful lot about the quality of the show. It’s good enough to work, but that’s a potentially low bar. How good is it, really? How much of the darkness is actually earned?
In my mind, some of it is earned. Shigofumi addresses certain topics well. Others might feel more exploitative, and where a viewer draws the line could be subjective. Putting that aside, most of the letter of the week scenarios are… functional. Few are much more than that. The Fumika plot is stronger, and it needs the off-plot letters in order to have the room it needs to grow, and especially to get us to connect with Mika.
But, there’s an elephant in the room, and its name is Boogiepop. When I look at the two shows, Boogiepop was never this hard to watch, and it aced with flying colors its need to make the supernatural alter-ego of a schoolgirl personable and connectable despite said entity being a weird distant something, and it did that in one episode. Everything Shigofumi wanted to be, Boogiepop surpassed it on. So obviously, Shigofumi has to get a lower grade than that.
And in my mind, that ends up being quite a bit lower. I’ll issue Shigofumi a C+. It has some artistic skills, but its material just isn’t stronger than average. I think if we’d had the twist earlier, and had gotten a few more episodes like the 13th that really built on the concept, it would have made the B’s, but as it is I’m going to say its delivery rates on the sunny side of standard.